
The Aquarian Weekly (A-): "As far as 'Black Gives Way', it's not the best Alice in Chains record...but it's pretty damn good, on its own merits and against the band's catalog... such strong songwriting still on display...There's something stunning about Cantrell and Alice in Chains' ability to make songs like "Check My Brain" and "Acid Bubble" this far into his career, which may put the band back on track to be one of the most celebrated acts of a generation after an unfortunate derailing seven years ago."
The Times (4/5): "While they still bludgeon with hard-edged chugs and drones, there are also majestic choruses ('Check My Brain') darkly atmospheric ballads ('Your Decision'; or the title track, with help from Elton John of all people) and plenty of classic-rock guitar flourishes, courtesy of Jerry Cantrell."
Spin (2.5/5): "'Alice in Chains still have an appealing outcast aura on their first studio album in 14 years...And while William DuVall is a serviceable Staley impressionist, this comeback would register with more purpose had guitarist Jerry Cantrell assumed the vocal lead. Instead, DuVall warbles misanthropically over too many muddy, grunge-era grind-a-thons (even Elton John's piano cameo on the poignant title track feels '90s retro)."
The Skinny (4/5): "But there's an overriding sense of survival in their [Cantrell and DuVall's] couplets, where bluesy shards of metal like 'Last of My Kind' etch a picture of a battle-hardened band plunging their tattered flag deeper into the dirt...AIC go vintage as often as they surprise with this fourth LP. Against some odds, it's a compelling start to a second act."

1. There is alot of old AIC in this new cd so most fans will have no problem picking it up and nodding right along with it. By far not there best work but not forgettable in the least more than worth a listen. The Crunchy churning guitar riffs are there just like they should be. The vocals in places are eerily similar to Layne but never in a outright copying way. Highlights for me were "All Secrets Known" and "Acid Bubble". with any luck they will putting music of this quality for years to come.
Posted at 12:36PM on Oct 3rd 2009 by Michael