



















2. Crush is my hands down favorite, although some of the others are very good. David Archuleta's voice is just one in a million. He opens his mouth to sing and out comes his heart.
Posted at 12:50PM on Jan 12th 2010 by hollyre
3. Yes, Crush is master of all Idol singles.
Posted at 12:53PM on Jan 12th 2010 by barbs
4. YAY!! David Archuleta is THE MAN!!
Posted at 12:58PM on Jan 12th 2010 by caitlin
5. Permanent is so beautiful and so deeply moving especially when you have experienced the loss or illness of a loved one. David Cook sings it so beautifully because he feels it to the core of his very soul. I love David Cook and all of his music because he brings each song to life with his gorgeous full ranged voice and especially on stage.
And what a rock star. The man is amazing live.
ladynsearch
Posted at 1:12PM on Jan 12th 2010 by ritreat2
6. Great choices. One correction though, the name of the charity David Cook's live performance of Permanent raised funds for is Accelerate Brain Cancer Cure (www.abc2.org).
Posted at 1:59PM on Jan 12th 2010 by D
7. Crush is the best song ever! Great choice. I never ever get tired of it!
Posted at 2:10PM on Jan 12th 2010 by peacesignpam
8. Are you calling Miss Independent and A Moment Like This unsuccessful singles? Really? Seriousy...really? I must've lived on another planet during that time because every time I turned the radio on, one of those songs was on. Try doing your research sometime. Let's also not forget Kelly's sold over 20+ albums worldwide. That's probably not worth mentioning though. Oh and as for Simon calling her success from Day 1...wrong again. He actually didn't care whether she went to Hollywood or not and couldn't remember her name when she got there. Randy and Paula were the ones on the spot.
Posted at 3:36PM on Jan 12th 2010 by Sarah
9. Someone didn't do their homework ... the writer says the violence in "Before He Cheats" happens because a girl wants to take action BEFORE her boyfriend cheats ... however, the car damage occurs AFTER he cheats, and she says it will make him think before he cheats AGAIN, and that if he cheats again it won't be on her.
Posted at 2:20PM on Jan 12th 2010 by Karen
10. I love Adam Lambert's song Whataya Want from Me, it's touchingly beautiful.
Posted at 2:23PM on Jan 12th 2010 by Marilyn
11. I love Crush and still listen it everyday! Hope David goes back to Nashville/LA/NY soon to work on his next pop cd after his charity work now in Central America. I miss not hearing from him eventhough it's only been a week!
Really excited about listening to David's new music on AOL again asap!
Posted at 2:40PM on Jan 12th 2010 by jessie
12. Live like we dying - great song for Kris.
Posted at 4:07PM on Jan 12th 2010 by JoCeeeee
13. I think Adam Lambert's song should be number one. His entire album is awesome! His vocals are beyond that of any singer I have ever heard! I love the fact that his album is so unique and has such variety. After hearing it I bought 3 more!
Posted at 1:46AM on Jan 13th 2010 by imagery31
14. Love love love Crush and the singer is pretty awesome too! And I love No Air. That song is just timeless, as well as live like we're dying! Those are three of my favorites!!
Thanks!!
Posted at 5:43PM on Jan 12th 2010 by Lynn
15. I love "Crush" and can listen to it over & over and never get tired of it!! David Archuleta is amazing!!
Posted at 6:14PM on Jan 12th 2010 by crmoriarty
16. They all sound alike. Idol will be suffering this season, and especially next year, if they make it on the air.
Good bye Paula and Simon. Ellen Degenerate blew ratings already..
Posted at 6:51PM on Jan 12th 2010 by Vicki
17. Crush? I liked it, but after a while it became waaaayyy too cheesy. Like, I almost barfed. That's as teeny bopper as it gets. Shame Achie had to sing that song; he's got mad talent. For me, it'd be a tie between "Whataya Want from Me" and "Permanent". Or even Kelly's singles. Sorry, but this list is ridic.
Posted at 7:53PM on Jan 14th 2010 by tennis
18. Very unimpressed. Some great and some have had no noticeable radio play. Looks more like a personal play list.
Posted at 8:14PM on Jan 12th 2010 by Idol8fan
19. Agreed Idol8fan. Very unimpressive list.
Posted at 10:28PM on Jan 12th 2010 by Idol7fan
20. love adam lambert. rocky start, but great album. live and learn.
Posted at 10:39PM on Jan 12th 2010 by michelle
21. I'm really amazed that Crush is number one that song is truly my favorite song!!! The song suited him soo perfectly. David Archuleta was amazing on Idol and he's still going strong so I'm very proud of him!! Congrats David you deserve it!! Some people think only the winners make it big look it people like David A. And Chris Daughtry, Elliot yamen and so many more that have done amazing even after not winning! So once again congrats David and crush will always be in our hearts!!!
Posted at 12:42AM on Jan 14th 2010 by Smileyarchie101
22. I enjoyed Breakaway by Kelly Clarkson when it came out. she is very talented and a great singer. Like someone said, it's hard to choose because I enjoy No Air and Katherine McPhee's Over It.I think David Archuleta's Crush is the best on the list, however. The tune is very catchy and current and the "away...yay...yay...yay" always gets to me. it's different and he does it so well. He has a great voice. Hope he makes more hits for his next project. It would be a waste of his great talent if his next album tanks.
Posted at 10:23AM on Jan 13th 2010 by gracie
23. I have heard many covers of CRUSH by others, but none can beat the original. His emo & gorgeous tone of voice makes this song touch deep inside. His low register is rich and his high register is soaring. I heard him live and his voice is even richer than this MP3 version. His voice is powerful three dimensional that is so resonant that it reaches every corner of a music theater.
Posted at 1:14AM on Jan 13th 2010 by john
24. LOVE CRUSH!!!
Posted at 9:31PM on Jan 13th 2010 by fairangel
25. David Archuleta is an amazing singer / songwriter. Loved "Crush" and I still hear it on the radio every once in a while. Yeah...go David!
Posted at 7:34AM on Jan 13th 2010 by TrudyFOD
26. "Over the past eight seasons, here are the Top 'American Idol' Songs that have been successful on the airwaves and rated by AOL Radio listeners."
It's not a "personal" playlist -read the intro. "Crush" is a super pop song (just short of 2M downloads) and David Archuleta is well -loved. During its run it was consistently rated at the top at AOL. It belongs at no. 1 for the year. Go David!
Posted at 8:53AM on Jan 13th 2010 by dani
27. David Cook is great, wonderful voice. Archie had a great voice, I guess he was to young and had a father that could not shut his mouth. Kris Allen, when I hear him sing I want to fall asleep, he has no entertaining skills, he sings ok, nothing great, and he won AI, above Adam Lambert, will never understand that. Adam Lambert has a voice and range that I have never heard before, he is a true entertainer, he brings out the happiness people have been waiting for plus being beyond good looking. Adam is a star.
Posted at 9:56AM on Jan 13th 2010 by eddiejerbso4
28. While Home got a lot of airplay and is a good Daughtry choice for this list my favorite was Over You.
Posted at 12:26PM on Jan 13th 2010 by Barb
29. We love Crush and David A.
Posted at 12:27PM on Jan 13th 2010 by bishpoul
30. I STILL think David Archuleta was WAAAAY better than David Cook.... (JMO)
Posted at 1:53PM on Jan 13th 2010 by Catherine
31. @ Adam Lambert's Whataya Want From Me?
VERY GOOD!
Posted at 2:12PM on Jan 13th 2010 by Catherine
32. I agree with Crush by David Archuleta being number 1. I love that song and the singer! Home, No Air, Before He Cheats, and Breakaway are also great.
Posted at 4:42PM on Jan 13th 2010 by music_speaks
33. Jordin's NO AIR, and Adam's WHATAYA WANT are catchy and unforgettable.
Posted at 10:54AM on Jan 14th 2010 by Mercy
34. Love David Archuleta's song Crush, this young man was born to sign plan and simple. Loved both albums so far and I can't wait to hear his next pop album.
Posted at 5:23PM on Jan 13th 2010 by whammy
35. David Archuleta has a VOICE that I have to listen to everyday. He just makes me smile!
Posted at 6:24PM on Jan 13th 2010 by Kathy C.
36. What about Clay Aiken? His single Solitaire was one of the most beautiful recordings as well as he is one of the top entertainers/singers to come out of the Idol franchise. As for Adam Lambert,we would rather prop howler monkey up in our livingroom and let it screech, same thing as listening to him. We are boycotting this season of Idol because of last seasons shameless effort to cram Adam Lambert down our throats, one can only hope that the truth about his lack of talent will allow him to fade into obscurity. Kelly Clarkson will always have a place in our heart as the queen for she is the first diva to come out of the idol spotlight. What a tremendous talent and voice for our young girls to emulate.
Posted at 12:58AM on Jan 14th 2010 by Will
37. The best song would be "No more, no more" or "The Last Song" or "Never Again" or my personal favorite "Cancel this crap before I die from a brain hemorrhage" !!
Posted at 12:20AM on Jan 14th 2010 by csi8299
38. Jason Castro is my all time favorite IDOL and his new EP LOVE UNCOMPROMISED will be a hit... jasoncastromusic.com
Posted at 12:46AM on Jan 14th 2010 by Tanya
39. Jason Castro is my all time favorite American Idol... his new EP LOVE UNCOMPROMISED will be a huge success! jasoncastromusic.com
Posted at 12:47AM on Jan 14th 2010 by Pluckytan
40. David Cook's premiere CD is SOOOOOOOOOOO awesome...it's hard to pick a fav...and if y'all EVER get a chance to hear him live, you'll recognize true talent!!! ROCK ON, Cookie!!!!!!
Posted at 1:08AM on Jan 14th 2010 by Vicki
41. Adam Lambert's Whataya Want From Me? is GREAT and it showcases his amazing voice! He's gorgeous, charming, well spoken, and an incredible performer and I look forward to many more fantastic albums!
Posted at 2:17AM on Jan 14th 2010 by DianneVV
42. Although Kelly and Adam are my favorite AI contestants, out of a list of many, there are a few songs that really touch my heart;
1. Home - Daughtrey
2. Jesus Take the Wheel - Carrie
3. A Moment Like This - Kelly
These songs give me goosebumps!
Posted at 4:24AM on Jan 14th 2010 by Stephanie Lanos
43. My favorite artist is Adam Lambert, his vocal range and skills cannot be denied as the very best ..... ever. I will not be watching AI again until they limit the # of votes per method.
Posted at 6:32AM on Jan 14th 2010 by Rita
44. Love Crush. Love David. He deserves to be at the top of any musical list. Nuf said.
Posted at 8:56AM on Jan 14th 2010 by Amy
45. this list was voted on by the listeners?must have been taken at jr. high or the mall.cant really fathom archuletta over underwood,but clarkson in third?really?clarkson set the bar very high and (get this america)song selection vocal range,airplay and album sales should put clarkson at #1.underwood at a solid second.clarkson's version of cant live(if living is without you)to me,was so powerfull that it put her at the forefront of the idol picks from any season.just another opinion.
Posted at 8:42AM on Jan 14th 2010 by wilbo
46. What about Fantasia & Rueben? They may have not gone on to superstar status, and their albums may not have sold well, but both are revered in the black community!!!!! And both are very talented vocalists!!!
Posted at 9:24AM on Jan 14th 2010 by Derek Perry
47. and even though she did not win, what about Jennifer Hudson?
Posted at 9:32AM on Jan 14th 2010 by Derek Perry
48. Elliot Yamins' performance of Moody's Mood for for Love, Fantasia's performance of Summertime, and I cannot recall the song, but Paris Bennett sang her face off!!! So did Syesha Mercado
Posted at 9:42AM on Jan 14th 2010 by Derek Perry
49. Sorry, anyone who would put the sickeningly sweet far to pop Crush at number 1 obviously knows nothing about music. It was Archie's one and only teen heart throb hit. I predict it will be his ONLY hit ever, as the teens and tweens are moving on to Justin Beiber. I have never gotten the impression that Archie was cut out for the music business.
Some of the best songs ever sung on Idol are missing from this list...Carrie's "I'll Stand By You" from Idol Gives Back, Bo Bice's acapella rendition of "In A Dream" and Adam Lambert's "Mad World", David Cook's "Billie Jean", Jennifer Hudson's "Circle of Life" just to mention a few.
Posted at 10:04AM on Jan 14th 2010 by Hannah
50. Wait until Adam releases "Fever", "Strut", and several others on his album! Whataya Want From Me" is great but there are other songs on his album that do rival this one!! Go Adam!!!
Posted at 12:27PM on Jan 14th 2010 by laura
Please keep your comments relevant to this blog entry. Off-topic, promotional or otherwise inappropriate comments will be removed.
1. Most of these are such great songs that it would be hard to rank one over the other but if imo, "Crush" was the best. David's voice combined with the catchy melody and the lyrics that we can all relate to make it my favorite.
Posted at 5:37PM on Jan 12th 2010 by Sevgi